
I first wrote about Booking dot com on this blog in 2012, when I was still running my own B&B in Champagne and many of my mentoring clients were telling me how much business the big booking sites brought them. “But at what cost?” I asked then, and I’m still asking now. This is an update of that post, because the question hasn’t gone away. If anything, it has got bigger.
For the record: in 17 years of running my B&B I never listed with Booking dot com, Airbnb or any other third-party platform, and the B&B still went from around €10,000 a year to €103,495. But many of the owners I’ve coached since 2014 have listed with them, so I know the problems and the headaches first-hand. Here is how the commission works, what else you hand over, and the three systems I use with my clients to reduce their reliance on the sites, step by step.
How Booking dot com commission actually works
The principle is simple. You list your rooms on the site for free, and every time a guest books through it, you pay the site a percentage of that booking. Across the big online travel agents, that percentage is between 15% and 30% of each booking, and the higher figures usually buy you more visibility on their pages. On a £150 room, that is £22.50 to £45 for every night sold, for the privilege of having them do your job, which is marketing.
That percentage is the part everyone talks about. It is not the expensive part.
What else you hand over
In my book I list the real issues with relying on a third-party platform, and I’ll share the ones that matter most here.
- You can’t communicate your unique value. Your listing looks and sounds like everyone else’s, so you become a commodity in a marketplace where the only lever is price.
- You’re not in charge of your prices. Yes, really. The sites will sometimes reduce them to “make you more attractive”, without telling you.
- They play with your position. One day you’re on page one for your area, the next day you’re nowhere to be seen. That is their decision, not yours.
- They keep your guests’ details. Above all, the email address. Owning your own list of guests, with when they stayed, what they came for and what they liked, is crucial to the long-term viability of your business. The sites have built enormous databases at your expense, and they can cut you off in a heartbeat.
- Part of your commission advertises your competitors. A portion of what you pay is spent promoting other properties, maybe the one down your street.
And then there are the guests. People who shop on the booking sites are often looking for a great deal, meaning a cheaper price. They are more likely to cancel at the last minute when they find something cheaper, and they are not always the guests you’d choose. In my experience, once roughly 30% of your bookings come through the sites, they have the power in your business, and when it passes 50%, you’re in what I call the wilderness: paying commission left, right and centre, unable to relate to your guests, and lying awake at night worrying about the next review.
Do the booking sites have a place at all?
Yes, and I want to be fair about this. If you don’t yet know how to identify and attract your ideal guest, the sites can bring bookings while you learn. They can fill a gap in a quiet week. And some of my clients use them deliberately, as a small top-up, with their own direct bookings as the foundation. What I don’t want for you is the situation most owners drift into, where the sites are the foundation and the direct bookings are the top-up. They are not a long-term strategy. Leave them to the big hotel chains.
If you’d like to know how much is riding on each site in your own business, my free B&B Income Calculator will show you what your rooms make at your own rates and occupancy, so you can see what a direct booking is worth to you compared with the same booking through a site.
How to reduce your reliance, step by step
The way out is not to delete your listing tomorrow. It is to build the three systems that make the listing unnecessary, and then let it shrink. These are the systems at the heart of my book, and they work in this order.
Step 1: Own the relationship with every guest who books
Wherever a booking comes from, the guest is now yours to look after. Get your own website and online booking system in place, so people who find you on a site can book you directly next time, and set up a customer relationship (CRM) system to hold your guests’ details. Then, the moment a booking lands, start the relationship: a friendly email thanking them, a short welcome video so they can see who they’ll be meeting, and two or three emails before they arrive inviting them to add something to their stay, with one of them about food and drink. People love to buy, and a guest who has bought a dinner or a tour from you does not cancel when a cheaper room pops up online. This is where your five-star review begins, and it’s how a site booking becomes a direct guest for life.
Step 2: Bring your past guests back
Your past guests already know, like and trust you. A regular information email from you, fortnightly or monthly, about what’s happening in your area, and a genuinely exciting offer two or three times a year, not a discount, gives you repeat bookings you can predict, and that is what ends the low-season worries. Most owners never do this because they’re afraid of bothering people. The guests who don’t want to hear from you will unsubscribe. The rest will book.
Step 3: Attract new guests without the sites
This is the one I call “educate, entertain and engage”. Write a free guide to your area, six to eight attractions with your personal take on each, and offer it on your website and all your social media accounts in return for a first name and an email address. Then a short automated sequence of five to seven emails builds the relationship, with an incentive to book in the last one. You are now building a list of future guests that no platform can take from you. I go into exactly how to write the guide in my post on how B&Bs create content for more direct bookings.
Step 4: Let the listing shrink
As your direct bookings grow, close the sites to your best dates first: weekends, high season, the weeks you can fill yourself. Keep them for the gaps, if you keep them at all. Watch the share of your bookings that comes through them fall month by month, and when it’s small enough that losing it wouldn’t hurt, you’re free to decide whether you need them at all. I wrote about the difference this makes in How to Enjoy More Income, with Less Work, and Pay Less Commission.
The question to keep asking
Back in 2012 I wrote that we need to ask ourselves, “What is it that I do which is unique, and that guests appreciate the most?” If the answer doesn’t come immediately, keep asking, or better still, ask some past guests. When you focus on adding value and providing a quality experience, you’ll have no need of the big booking sites. You’ll be minding your own business and in charge of your own destiny. Is it time to let Booking dot com go and serve someone else?
Where to go next
All three systems are laid out step by step in my book, How to Start, Run and Grow a B&B Business that You and Your Guests Love, which comes with its own built-in AI assistant so you can ask it about your own set-up. And if you’d like to talk through how reliant you are and where to start, book a free 15-minute call with me.
Frequently asked questions
How much commission does Booking dot com charge a B&B?
The online travel agents take between 15% and 30% of each booking, with the higher rates generally buying more visibility on their pages. Your own agreement will state your exact rate.
Should a new B&B list on Booking dot com?
If you don’t yet know how to find your ideal guests, it can bring bookings while you learn. But treat it as a stopgap, not a strategy, and build your website, booking system and guest list from day one so you can rely on it less each season.
Can a small B&B really survive without Booking dot com?
Mine did for 17 years, from two rooms to four, and went from around €10,000 a year to €103,495 with no listings on any third-party platform. It takes a website that speaks to your ideal guest, an online booking system, and a guest list you look after.
What is the fastest way to reduce my reliance on the booking sites?
Start with the guests you already have. Set up the welcome and pre-arrival emails so every site booking becomes a direct guest next time, then make an offer to your past guests. Those two steps alone bring in bookings you’re not paying commission on.
